Instructional Design Models (ADDIE vs ID4T)

 

As we learn instructional design in our second week of class, we were required to compare two instructional design models, which is ID4T to any other model. As for me, I pick the ADDIE model as a comparison to ID4T.

ADDIE

The ADDIE model is one of the most famous types of model in instructional design. This model retained a five step approach, which is also much more detailed in its' subset. The five steps are Analyze, Design, Develop, Implement, and Evaluate formed the name, ADDIE.




ID4T

ID4T or Instructional Design For Teachers is also a model for instructional designs. The model is split into nine processes. The creator Carr-Chellman suggests in this model for educators to be “creative with your activities/media, test your instruction, revise, do instructional design all the time”.


Comparison between ID4T & ADDIE model


ID4T

ADDIE

Nine steps

·         Setting goal

·         Create learning objectives

·         Analyse student characteristics

·         Wring test

·         Selecting material

·         Develop activities

·         Selecting media

·         Implementing lesson

·         Revising lesson

Five steps

·         Analyse

                                i.            Environment

                              ii.            Students

                            iii.            Contents

·         Design

                                i.            To suit the objectives

                              ii.            To suit the students

·         Develop

                                i.            Based on the design

·         Implement

                                i.            Making tests/trials on colleagues, friends

                              ii.            Make a questionnaire for feedback

·         Evaluate

                                i.            The students

                              ii.            Using assessments

 

Mainly focused on the students

Focus on students but act as a basis for teachers/educators

Can be done in hierarchal order and can be done by repeating the steps to complete the process

Have to complete the process step by step in hierarchal order

Conclusion

Despite both of the models is pretty different on their own, both, ID4T model and the ADDIE model, can be used in conjunction together. As both focus on teaching, types of teaching, and evaluating students, applying both models together could help and increase the education process in the classroom.

That is all for today. :)

Source image: Google Images

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Flipped Classroom - YouTube

Image
 Assalamualaikum and a very good day to all readers. As it has been 8 weeks of learning, there is so much that I have learned. In this week's lesson, we were tasked to write our opinion on the way or platform for the flipped classroom. The one that I have chosen is YouTube. YouTube is not something new for anyone anymore. The application is useful for anyone to use to watch videos of learning, fun, lifestyle, foods, and, etc. As a student, we mainly use YouTube as a platform for learning. Since the start of online distance learning, YouTube was one of the main platforms for lecturers to post their videos of lectures and teaching. As the video is posted on YouTube, it makes learning so much easier as some of us students have internet connection problems. By this, we are able to watch it any other time when our connection is much more stable. Aside from that, lecturers have also linked a video from YouTube itself as additional materials for us to look at. As YouTube is a massive plat...
Read more

Universal Design for Learning Classroom - Flipped Learning

Image
 Assalamualaikum and a very good day readers. Currently, right now I am writing on week 9 of our lesson. For this week, we learned on UDL or Universal Design for Learning, where this topic focuses on the flexibility of learning for all various needs of students. In my personal teaching approach for my classroom, I would prefer to use flipped learning to ease my students. As mathematics would not be the easiest for all students, I think that applying flipped learning will let students feel much easier at learning this subject. This is because flipped learning allows students to read and understand a certain topic first before attending class. Hence, allowing them to be prepared for what we would learn during class. In addition, letting students read on a certain topic first, will allow teachers to know which topics or chapters that is the hardest for them. By that, teachers could focus more on certain topics with the students, thus, helping each of the students to understand that to...
Read more